The Intermediate State of the Dead and David in Acts 2:34

Acts 2:34 is a clear and important statement: "For David is not ascended into the heavens." Peter uses this to demonstrate that Psalm 110:1—"The LORD said unto my Lord, Sit thou at my right hand, until I make thine enemies thy footstool"—cannot be referring to David himself, since David is not at the Father’s right hand. The verse also opens a window into the state of the dead under the law.

Taken in its immediate context, the statement simply affirms that David is not enthroned in heaven. It does not, by itself, specify where David is, but the wider biblical pattern points to Sheol (or Hades), the waiting place of the dead, rather than to heaven.

If we survey the Old Testament view of the dead, we consistently find them going “down” to Sheol, the grave, or the pit, not “up” to heaven. This applies to both righteous and wicked, though their experience within that realm is not the same. Peter’s remark about David fits that pattern. In the dispensation of the law (and earlier), even saints who will one day be part of Israel’s future kingdom are not pictured as ascended to heaven. They are awaiting resurrection.

From that pattern, you draw the conclusion that no one has ascended to heaven except Christ and that no one will until the first resurrection. The first part is certainly true in a unique sense: Christ alone has ascended to the Father’s right hand as the exalted, resurrected man. The question is whether all believers in the present dispensation share the same intermediate experience as David and the Old Testament saints.

Here we must consider passages in Paul that speak about the believer’s state after death in this age. Philippians 1:23 is crucial:

"For I am in a strait betwixt two, having a desire to depart, and to be with Christ; which is far better."

Paul’s desire is “to depart, and to be with Christ.” In your view, you rightly affirm that Christ is in heaven, having ascended there. To "depart, and to be with Christ" naturally implies a conscious presence with Him where He is. It does not sound like departing to a separate realm removed from Christ’s presence.

Added to this, 1 Thessalonians 4:14 says:

"For if we believe that Jesus died and rose again, even so them also which sleep in Jesus will God bring with him."

The simplest reading is that, when Christ comes from heaven, those who have “sleep in Jesus” are already with Him and are brought along as He descends. This harmonizes well with Paul’s longing in Philippians 1 and suggests that the dead in Christ are presently with the Lord.

Colossians 3:3–4 also contributes to the picture:

"For ye are dead, and your life is hid with Christ in God. When Christ, who is our life, shall appear, then shall ye also appear with him in glory."

Believers’ lives are now “hid with Christ in God,” and when He appears, they appear with Him. That expectation again assumes a close association of the believer with Christ between death and the resurrection event.

Taken together, these Pauline texts indicate that, in the present dispensation of grace, those who die in Christ are with Him. Since He has ascended into heaven, the most straightforward conclusion is that departed believers are in His presence in heaven, awaiting resurrection, rather than in the Sheol/Hades state that characterized saints of prior dispensations.

Therefore, Acts 2:34 robustly supports your view about David and other saints under the law: they did not ascend to heaven, and their hope centers on resurrection and entrance into the kingdom. But we must recognize a dispensational shift with the revelation given to Paul. The pattern for Old Testament saints does not, by itself, define the experience of the body of Christ.

Acts 2:34, then, backs your thoughts with regard to David and the earlier dispensations, but the Pauline material points to a distinct, blessed intermediate state for those in Christ today: to depart is to be with Christ, where He is, prior to the resurrection and glorification to come.

questiontransition