The Non-Imputation of Sin in the Present Age

The common evangelical position is that an individual's sins are held against him or her until the person believes the gospel, at which point those sins are forgiven and no longer imputed. Under that view, unbelievers die with their sins imputed, are judged on that basis, and suffer eternal damnation because their sins remain their own.

I believe Scripture presents a different picture for this present age of grace: God is not imputing the world's trespasses to it. That statement concerns God's present stance toward the world, not the final destiny of individuals, and it applies universally, not merely to believers.

Not Imputing Trespasses: What Scripture Says

A central text is 2 Corinthians 5:19:

"To wit, that God was in Christ, reconciling the world unto himself, not imputing their trespasses unto them."

Notice:

• It is the world that is in view, not a subset defined as believers.
• The description is of God's stance: "not imputing their trespasses unto them."
• There is no textual indication that "world" here means only Jews, or only Christians, or any narrowed category.

To restrict "world" to believers or any subgroup is an insertion into the text. As written, God in Christ is reconciling the world to himself and is not imputing its trespasses.

Romans 5 sheds light on this. Romans 5:12–14 says:

"Wherefore, as by one man sin entered into the world, and death by sin; and so death passed upon all men, for that all have sinned: (For until the law sin was in the world: but sin is not imputed when there is no law. Nevertheless death reigned from Adam to Mosesdots)"

Important observations:

• Before the Mosaic law, "sin was in the world," but "sin is not imputed when there is no law."
• Yet, "Nevertheless death reigned." So the absence of imputation does not mean the absence of death, separation, or judgment.
• Imputation of sin and the reign of death are related but not identical concepts; they must not be collapsed into one.

In this present age, we are not under the Mosaic law as a covenant. There is, in that sense, a parallel: sin exists, but God is not presently imputing trespasses while extending a gracious offer. That non-imputation does not entail universal salvation. Death still reigns; people remain separated from God if they do not receive his gift.

Thus, I would answer your first question:

• In the age of grace, God is not imputing the world's sins to it.
• That is true of all humanity, not only of believers.
• This does not mean everyone is saved, nor does it teach universalism.

The danger is to commit a non sequitur: "If sins are not imputed, then all go to heaven." Scripture never makes that move. It rather shows that although sin is not being imputed in this age, death and separation from God still reign for those who do not receive the offered gift.

Why Judgment Still Exists Without Imputed Sin

If no one's sins are being imputed in this age, why do people perish? Because the fundamental issue is not a running ledger of particular sins, but the Adamic condition of separation from God and the rejection of his gracious gift.

Adam's one sin brought death to all (Romans 5:12). That death (separation) continues regardless of how God is handling the accounting of trespasses at a given time. In this age, God has set aside the immediate legal reckoning of trespasses and is offering a free gift of reconciliation in Christ. Those who refuse that gift remain in Adam, under death.

So we must distinguish:

• Imputation of trespasses (God's present accounting stance), and
• The Adamic death condition and ultimate exclusion from life for those who do not receive his gift.

Non-imputation is the backdrop for a genuine, open offer; it does not itself guarantee eternal life.

If Sins Are Not Imputed, Why Does Homosexuality Matter?

Your follow-up question presses the practical and moral implications: if sins are not being held against any of us, why does a particular sin---such as homosexuality---matter at all? Why object to homosexual pastors or same-sex marriages? Why do Christians warn others if God is not counting trespasses?

First, it is essential to state clearly: if God is not imputing trespasses, then a homosexual person does not go to hell because of homosexuality, any more than an adulterer goes to hell because of adultery, or a liar because of lying. Eternal destiny is determined by whether a person remains in Adam or is in Christ, not by the catalog of particular acts.

Yet the non-imputation of sin does not erase:

• The created order of humanity,
• The inherent consequences of actions, and
• The call to live in ways that reflect God's character and design.

Created Purpose Versus Misuse

We are made in the image of God, with a created design. That design includes the complementary nature of male and female, and the place of sexual expression within a covenantal, monogamous marriage between a man and a woman. When we act contrary to that design, we may still be under non-imputation of trespasses in this age, but we are misusing what God has made, like using a ruler as a screwdriver:

• You can use a metal ruler to turn a screw. It may even work in a pinch.
• But the ruler was not made for that purpose, so the use is awkward, limited, and often damaging.
• When you use the ruler to measure, its proper function, it is consistently helpful and satisfying.

So also with human sexuality and the broader shape of human life. Homosexual practice is not condemned because "God will count that sin and send you to hell," but because it is a misuse of the created order of male and female. It is contrary to the way human beings are wired to function most fruitfully and stably.

Thus, homosexuality "matters" not because it overcomes the cross or defeats grace, but because:

• It distorts the created pattern of male-female complementarity.
• It often introduces deep personal, relational, and societal complications.
• It does not align with the purpose for which our bodies and relationships were designed.

Why Object to Homosexual Pastors or Same-Sex Weddings?

You ask why, if God is not imputing trespasses, Christians object to homosexual pastors or same-sex marriages.

The answer lies in calling and representation, not in earning or losing salvation:

• A pastor is, by definition, one who publicly teaches and models truth. To live openly in a pattern contrary to the created order, while occupying a role of spiritual oversight, sends a contradictory message about God, Scripture, and holiness.
• A marriage ceremony is a public recognition and blessing of a union. To bless a union that does not reflect the male-female pattern established in creation is to normalize and affirm a pattern that runs against the biblical anthropology of human life and family.

Christians warn in such settings, not because they believe one particular sin uniquely blocks salvation in this age, but because they discern that:

• Certain patterns of life are fundamentally disordered, harmful, and confusing.
• Teaching people that such patterns are normal or blessed deepens their confusion and makes later recovery far more difficult.

This applies to many sins, not only homosexuality. You could replace homosexuality in your question with other serious, entrenched patterns of sin and ask the same. The principle is that leaders and official acts of the church must not legitimize or celebrate what is contrary to the Creator's design, even in an age when God is not imputing trespasses.

Grace as the Higher Motive

You rightly note, "We magnify Christ as living as righteously as possible." That phrase expresses the core motive for godly living in this age.

Paul anticipates the objection that you are wrestling with. In effect, he imagines someone saying:

"If God is so gracious, and if sin is not being imputed, why not sin more so that grace may abound?"

His response is emphatic: "God forbid." The logic of grace is not: "My actions no longer matter, so I will do whatever I please." Rather:

• We have been given an unmerited standing of peace with God.
• God is not imputing our trespasses in this age, but offering a free gift in Christ.
• Our response is to walk in a manner worthy of that gift, gladly reflecting the character and design of the One who saved us.

Fear of being "marked down" and sent to hell is a low and unstable motivator. Grace calls us to something higher: gratitude, love, and alignment with God's created intentions. Thus, when a believer faces temptation---sexual or otherwise---the most fitting response is not, "If I do this, will I still go to heaven?" but, "How can I, who have received such grace, live in a way that honors the One who gave it, and that is consistent with how he made me?"

In that light:

• God not imputing trespasses means the door of grace is wide open.
• It does not mean behaviors are morally neutral, harmless, or wise.
• It does mean that the call to righteousness is grounded in gratitude and design, not in fear of damnation for each misstep.

So your instinct is correct: God is not now counting trespasses in a way that immediately assigns eternal destiny, yet Christians are right to warn against lifestyles---including homosexual practice---that run contrary to our created nature and that confuse and damage those who adopt and embrace them, especially when such lifestyles are taught or modeled under the banner of Christian ministry.

questiontransition