Forgiveness, Tribulation Works, and the Question of Calvinist Salvation

Your question actually raises two related but distinct issues: (1) how forgiveness and works relate in the coming tribulation, and (2) how to think about the salvation of those who hold to Calvinist doctrine in this present dispensation.

Forgiveness at the Cross and the Tribulation

On the first point, I am comfortable saying, with some careful definition, that all sins were dealt with at the cross in such a way that God is now free to offer salvation by grace through faith, apart from works, to anyone. In 2 Corinthians 5:19, Paul says:

"God was in Christ, reconciling the world unto himself, not imputing their trespasses unto them..."

In other studies I have argued that "forgiveness" and "non-imputation" are essentially two ways of describing the same act from different angles. God is not counting our sins against us because of what Christ accomplished at Calvary.

In this present dispensation, then:

• Salvation is offered on the basis of grace alone, through faith alone, apart from works.
• Once a person believes the gospel of grace, he or she is saved, secure, and part of the one body of Christ.
• That salvation is not lost even if the believer later fails or becomes confused doctrinally.

This situation, however, is tied specifically to the current administration of grace and to the unique entity called the body of Christ. That arrangement does not continue indefinitely.

When the body of Christ is removed at the rapture, God will resume His dealings with Israel under the covenants and promises given long before Paul. At that point, the program in operation will not be the same as the one described in Paul's epistles.

In the tribulation period, passages such as the Gospels and Hebrews come to the forefront, with their strong emphasis on enduring to the end and on works as a demonstration and requirement within Israel's covenantal context. Under that program:

• The cross is still the ultimate basis upon which God can save.
• Yet the terms of the offer to Israel, as expressed in their covenants and prophetic promises, include obedience, faithfulness, and endurance.

So the fact that the cross objectively settled the sin question does not mean that God must always and everywhere offer salvation on the same terms. He is free, as Lord of both the dead and the living (Romans 14:9), to structure different dispensational arrangements while always remaining consistent with the once-for-all work of Christ.

The Present Dispensation and False Doctrine

Turning to the second part of your question: what about Calvinists today, with their serious doctrinal errors? Are they saved, or is Calvinism essentially "the opposite of truth to salvation"?

Calvinism constructs a very different system of salvation than the Pauline gospel of grace. Its core elements can be summarized as follows:

• Unconditional election: God chose certain individuals before the foundation of the world.
• Limited atonement: Christ died only for those elect individuals.
• Irresistible grace: God regenerates the elect, enabling them to believe.
• Perseverance of the saints: True believers necessarily continue in faith and good works to the end.

In that system, a person is saved because he is elect; Christ died for him in particular; he is regenerated prior to faith; and his perseverance proves his status. Works to the end are, in this framework, indispensable evidence of genuine salvation.

That is, in many respects, a different gospel structure than what we see in Paul, where salvation is offered freely to all, conditioned only on faith, and where the atonement is not restricted to a pre-selected group.

Yet when you speak with a Calvinist at the simplest level and ask, "What must I do to be saved?" the answer you will usually hear is, "Believe on the Lord Jesus Christ, and you will be saved." The Calvinist, when he personally trusted Christ, did not consciously rely on his own works. He trusted that God was offering him salvation through the blood of Jesus Christ.

So we have a tension:

• On the one hand, Calvinism systematizes salvation in a way that mixes Israel's covenantal election with the present dispensation and adds a necessary, enduring works-component to verify salvation.
• On the other hand, many Calvinists, in their actual moment of faith, simply relied on Christ and His finished work, not on themselves.

Are Calvinists Saved?

Salvation in this dispensation is by grace through faith, not of works, not of doctrinal precision. That does not mean doctrine is unimportant—far from it. But it does mean that a person may be genuinely saved while holding many erroneous or even contradictory theological ideas.

A Calvinist who has truly trusted Christ—believing that God, on the basis of Christ's death and resurrection, saves all who believe—has placed faith in the right object, even though his theological system surrounding that faith is badly distorted.

We should therefore say:

• Calvinism as a system seriously corrupts the Pauline gospel and leads to confusion, burden, and often spiritual bondage.
• Nevertheless, many Calvinists are likely saved in spite of their system, not because of it, by simple faith in Christ.

The grace of God in this age is wide enough to save those whose trust is in Christ, even when their theological explanations are deeply flawed. The fact that their system cannot be reconciled with right division and with Paul's clear teaching does not necessarily mean that every individual adherent is lost.

Why Right Division Still Matters Profoundly

While we may acknowledge that God can save people who are doctrinally confused, we should not therefore become indifferent about doctrine. Calvinism, covenant theology, and other systems that ignore or deny right division:

• Obscure the freeness and security of grace.
• Misapply Israel's promises and warnings to the body of Christ.
• Burden believers with questions about their election, perseverance, and assurance.

Rightly dividing the word of truth clarifies the distinctiveness of Paul's message, preserves the pure grace of the gospel for today, and protects believers from systems that, though sometimes used by God to save, often hinder spiritual growth and biblical understanding.

So while I cannot draw a sharp, infallible line declaring all Calvinists unsaved or saved, I can say with confidence that Calvinism is a serious doctrinal error, incompatible with a clear Pauline understanding of this dispensation. It is therefore something to be resisted and corrected, even as we recognize that God's grace can and does reach people through a very foggy presentation of the truth.

newpage