Christ’s Promise to the Thief and the Nature of Paradise

The key statement is:

"And Jesus said unto him, Verily I say unto thee, To day shalt thou be with me in paradise.’’ (Luke 23:43)

The question arises because Jesus’ body was placed in the tomb and remained there until the resurrection on the third day. How then could He tell the thief, “Today shalt thou be with me in paradise”?

Death, the Body, and the Soul

Scripture clearly indicates that Jesus’ body did not leave the tomb before the resurrection. The burial and sealing of the tomb are described, and on the first day of the week the body is no longer there. Between death and resurrection, His body lay in the grave.

This necessitates a distinction between body and soul (and, we may add, spirit). At death, the body and the immaterial part of man separate. The body returns to the earth; the soul continues in conscious existence. In the case of Jesus and the repentant thief, their bodies died that day, but their souls did not cease to exist.

When Jesus says “Today,” the natural reading is temporal immediacy: the same calendar day on which both will die. This wording works strongly against the idea of “soul sleep,” in which the soul is unconscious in the grave until a future resurrection. The promise “Today shalt thou be with me in paradise” holds out conscious presence with Christ on that very day, not a long, dreamless interval.

The Meaning of "Paradise"

The term translated “paradise” (paradeisos) appears three times in the New Testament:

• Luke 23:43: “To day shalt thou be with me in paradise.”
• 2 Corinthians 12:4: Paul speaks of a man “caught up into paradise,” associated with being caught up to the “third heaven.”
• Revelation 2:7: “the tree of life, which is in the midst of the paradise of God.”

The word itself denotes a garden-like place of blessedness and delight. It does not, by itself, settle all questions of location or timing, but it clearly conveys positive, conscious well-being.

In Luke 16, Jesus describes the death of the beggar Lazarus, who is “carried by the angels into Abraham’s bosom.” There he is comforted, in contrast to the rich man in torment. Abraham’s bosom represents the abode of the righteous dead, a place of conscious comfort prior to the final resurrection.

It is reasonable to understand “paradise” in Luke 23:43 as referring to that place of the righteous dead. On the day of their deaths, the immaterial parts of Jesus (as man) and the repentant thief would both be in that realm of blessing, while Jesus’ body lay in the tomb.

How This Relates to the Three Days in the Grave

The three days refer to the period during which Jesus’ body was in the grave, from His death until His resurrection “the third day.” There is no necessity that His soul be confined to the rock-hewn tomb with His body. The clear force of His promise to the thief is that, while their bodies would die and be handled by men, they themselves—their conscious selves—would be together in paradise that very day.

This distinction:

• Preserves the reality of Jesus’ physical death and burial.
• Honors the immediacy and comfort of His promise to the thief.
• Affirms conscious existence after death for the righteous.

The thief’s experience, therefore, was not: “Today you and I will both merely lie unconscious in the ground.” It was: “Today, when death takes us from this cross, you and I will be together in a blessed, conscious realm of comfort before God.”

Implications

This passage has several implications:

• It strongly challenges the doctrine of soul sleep, since the promise implies awareness and companionship “today.”
• It underlines that death does not annihilate personal consciousness; rather, it involves separation of body and soul.
• It shows that for the believer (in that pre-resurrection setting), death led immediately to a realm of blessing, here called paradise.

While many details about paradise, Abraham’s bosom, the third heaven, and the intermediate state can be further explored and debated, the basic answer to the question is this: Jesus’ body was in the grave for three days, but His soul was not confined there. On the day of His death, His immaterial presence and that of the repentant thief were together in paradise, in conscious blessedness, exactly as He promised.

newpage