The Intended Audience of Romans 2 and Jewish Belief
Question: Someone asked if Paul wrote to unbelievers anywhere in Romans. Is Romans 2 for believing or unbelieving Jews? For the purposes of this question, when we talk about a believing or unbelieving Jew, we are distinguishing between Jews who simply believe the Tanakh and the God of Israel, and Jews who also believe that Jesus is the Messiah (the Christ). Is Romans 2 addressing Jews who believe that Jesus is the Christ, or Jews who do not, or is it broader than that?
To answer who is in view in Romans 2, it helps to trace the flow from the beginning of the epistle.
In Romans 1, Paul introduces himself as separated to "the gospel of God" promised beforehand in the prophets Romans 1:1–2, and then immediately connects that promised message to "his Son Jesus Christ our Lord" Romans 1:3. He identifies his readers as "the called of Jesus Christ" and "all that be in Rome, beloved of God, called to be saints" Romans 1:6–7. Their "faith is spoken of throughout the whole world" Romans 1:8.
Those descriptions can fit either believing Jews (who confess Jesus as Messiah) or devout Jews whose faithfulness under trial has become widely known. Paul desires to visit them to "impart unto you some spiritual gift, to the end ye may be established" Romans 1:11, indicating that they lack some key teaching—likely including the full revelation of the mystery and perhaps, for some, the identification of Jesus as the Christ.
When Paul speaks of "the gospel of Christ" in Romans 1:16, he describes it as the power of God unto salvation "to the Jew first, and also to the Greek." This emphasis on priority of the Jew points to a message that still recognizes Israel’s distinctive place; it is not yet the fully unfolded, Jew–Gentile-equal mystery gospel. Paul wants to preach this gospel "to you that are at Rome also" Romans 1:15, which suggests that not all in his Roman audience have yet embraced the gospel of Christ concerning Jesus as Messiah.
Turning to Romans 2, Paul begins:
Future Subscription: In the future a subscription may be required to read the full answer. But for now it is free!
"Therefore thou art inexcusable, O man, whosoever thou art that judgest..." Romans 2:1
He continues with a series of generic addresses: "O man" Romans 2:1,3. Up through about verse 16, the language remains broad and principial, speaking of God’s righteous judgment, wrath against impenitent hardness of heart, rendering to every man according to his deeds Romans 2:5–6, tribulation and anguish upon every soul of man that doeth evil "of the Jew first, and also of the Gentile" Romans 2:9, and glory and honor to those who work good, again "to the Jew first, and also to the Gentile" Romans 2:10. There is "no respect of persons with God" Romans 2:11.
This opening section of chapter 2 does not confine itself narrowly to Jews who believe that Jesus is the Christ. It sets out universal principles of divine judgment, applying to Jew and Gentile alike. In that sense, it addresses humanity in general, with special reference to how those principles relate first to the Jew and then to the Gentile. It can encompass both Jews who do not yet confess Jesus as Messiah and Gentiles who know only God as Creator and Judge.
From verse 17 onward, Paul clearly zeroes in on the Jew explicitly:
"Behold, thou art called a Jew, and restest in the law, and makest thy boast of God..." Romans 2:17
Here he clearly addresses Jews who rely on the law and boast in their covenant relationship with God. There is no explicit indication that these Jews already believe that Jesus is the Christ; rather, he is confronting the Jew who is confident in possessing the law and circumcision while failing to keep the law’s demands. His aim is to strip away false security based on mere Jewish identity and outward marks and to show the need for a deeper righteousness.
Given this, Romans 2 as a whole is best understood as:
- Verses 1–16: a general address to mankind in moral terms (Jew and Gentile), laying out principles of God’s righteous judgment, with special mention of the Jew–Gentile order but without limiting the audience to believers in Jesus.
- Verses 17–29: a specific address to the Jew who relies on the law and circumcision, whether or not he yet recognizes Jesus as Messiah.
In neither section is Paul clearly restricting himself to Jews who already confess Jesus as the Christ. Instead, he is preparing the ground to show, in chapters 3 and following, that all—Jew and Gentile alike—are under sin and in need of the righteousness which God provides.
So to your question: Romans 2 is not written narrowly to "believing Jews" in the sense of Jews who already recognize Jesus as Messiah, nor is it only to "unbelieving Jews" in that specialized sense. The early part of the chapter addresses humanity at large (with the Jew–Gentile structure in view), and the latter part addresses Jews as Jews, many of whom have not yet believed on Jesus. Paul is moving them from confidence in law and identity to the recognition of universal guilt and the necessity of God’s provided righteousness, which he will then expound.